Cup shocks harder to find as wider gap emerges

The hope surrounding a cup competition might be rooted in its tradition of upsets, late drama, and breakout heroes, but this weekend's FAI Cup second round feels more about predictability than possibility.

The draw has been kind – at least to the favourites – with none of the big hitters forced into early battles against one another. That's a shame if you’re hoping for chaos, but a blessing for clubs juggling European exploits and domestic pressures.

From the outset, it's hard to see any of the Premier Division elite slipping up.

The tie of the round, at least in name, is Dundalk hosting Sligo Rovers – but even that has a feeling of formality to it.

Sligo come into the fixture with growing momentum, their young squad increasingly in tune with John Russell’s methods. New signings have settled straight away, and they’ve added quality without disrupting their rhythm.

Dundalk and Sligo Rovers last met in the competition at the semi-final stage in 2019

Dundalk are flying high in the First Division under Ciarán Kilduff, who has propelled them into serious promotion contention. However, the gulf in quality between the two divisions remains significant, and stopping this in-form Sligo side is a major challenge.

Elsewhere, the top flight’s top sides have drawn opposition far enough down the footballing ranks to make any upset unlikely.

That’s not to dismiss the junior clubs involved – sides like Leicester Celtic and Crumlin United have rich histories and competitive squads – but the widening gap in conditioning and professionalism makes giant-killings a tougher ask than ever.

There was a time when a well-drilled amateur team could rattle a League of Ireland side. But modern football – especially at League of Ireland level – has changed.

Nutrition, sports science, and sleep routines are now as crucial as tactical plans.

These players are full-time in everything they do. And crucially, they’re in-season.

Match-sharp, tactically in-tune, and physically peaking. The amateur sides arrive into this round under prepared and outgunned.

We saw a gulf in conditioning laid bare over the last week.

Shelbourne and Linfield played out a tense European tie over two legs, with Linfield – for all their structure and belief – struggling to match Shelbourne’s relentless energy late in games.

Shelbourne were too good across both legs against Linfield

The main difference being Linfield are in pre-season and Shelbourne are in the middle of their campaign and at peak fitness levels.

So what hope for the amateur Crumlin United, facing the holders Drogheda United tonight?

Of course, the beauty of any cup is that belief can trump reason, if only on rare occasions.

But this weekend feels a little too grounded, a little too practical. That doesn’t mean there won’t be stories. For some clubs, this round could shape their season.

Take St Patrick’s Athletic. Stephen Kenny’s side make the trip south to face UCC in Cork, just days after last night’s impressive triumph in Lithuania in their European qualifier.

There’ll be tired legs, changes in personnel, and the challenge of motivation against a side they’re expected to brush aside.

For a club in indifferent league form, the competition might offer their clearest route back into Europe – especially now that the FAI Cup winners earn a Europa League qualifying spot rather than a place in the less lucrative Conference League.

Stephen Kenny celebrates Dundalk's 2016 FAI Cup final win

Expect Kenny to rotate, but not too much. With so much on the line, getting through is the priority – even if it takes grit over glamour.

Shelbourne face a different logistical challenge. Their European duties saw them return from Belfast midweek, and they now meet Fairview – a trip to Limerick.

The European draw couldn’t have been kinder. If Joey O’Brien had written it himself, he wouldn’t have asked for much better: a beatable opponent, minimal travel, and a manageable turnaround before their trip out west.

But even for Shels, the cup can be a distraction. When the stakes of European football include hundreds of thousands and into the millions in prize money and the kind of exposure most clubs dream of, it’s human nature to look ahead.

Preparation for Fairview and UCC will be focused, but the mental energy required to swing between competitions is real.

Still, this weekend shouldn’t throw up many surprises.

Not because teams won’t try – they will – but the gaps have never been greater.

Cup football used to be the great leveller. Now, professionalism does the levelling – in favour of the stronger, fitter, sharper side.

That doesn’t mean the FAI Cup has lost its magic. But maybe the upsets are harder to pull off then they once were.

Listen to the RTÉ Soccer podcast on Apple Podcasts, Spotify or wherever you get your podcasts.

Click here to read article